So I thought that these lais were pretty interesting, and I
didn’t mind reading them at all.
With Equitan, I was actually surprised at how similar the plot was to
some of our modern romances about couples who cheat. It started out with two
people who lusted after each other and realized all of the reasons why having
an affair would be wrong, but then said, “fuck it” and did it anyway. They were
caught, of course, and had to suffer the consequences, but death is just a bit
harsher than our normal punishments now a days. Also, I feel compelled to ask:
wouldn’t Equitan’s death have major
repercussions? I mean, yeah, he was a crap king and his seneschal did most of his work, but he was still the king and, since
he didn’t have a wife or heir, his death would have created massive problems
and probably thrown the area he ruled into turmoil. And the seneschal would have been put to death
for treason, so no real happy ending for him either.
Le
Fresne on the other hand, was a sweet story and I was actually happy to
find out that not all of their stories involved torture, death, and other
things like that. However, I have to admit that I was disappointed that the
mother didn’t have to face any sort of punishment for getting rid of one of her
daughters and never telling her husband about it. Also, she would rather kill
someone and go directly against her religion rather than have to deal with her
reputation taking a nosedive? What a vain woman. But then she goes ahead and
gives the child (that she was about to kill) this ridiculously expensive robe
and ring and sends her off to the monastery. I’m sorry, do you care about this
child or not? Your attitude just did a complete 180. But hey, I guess her
confessing and repenting at the end was enough to make up for this so…happy
ending for everyone!
Now Bisclavret was an odd story. One thing that I thought was weird was
how he couldn’t turn back into a human if he didn’t have his clothes. I mean,
who came up with that? That is such a random rule (although I guess only
changing during a full moon is a kind of random rule too). And his wife was absolutely
horrible. She begged and manipulated her husband into telling her all of his
secrets after promising that she would still love him, and then she turned
around and betrayed him immediately. Also, why did she keep his clothes around
after she took them? If she really wanted him to stay as a werewolf, then why
didn’t she just burn the clothes or something? I did, however, like her
punishment (and the nose less children idea was hilarious).
And did the king and Bisclavret
get together? Because they were kissing at the end but MarĂe de France didn’t really
mention anything else about it.
Overall,
these were some intriguing stories, even if I couldn’t stop my brain from
pointing out all of the little discrepancies. I realize that I just have to
accept the random ideas in the lais,
but it still bugs me.





